The British Election Debates-Are we going to opt for style over substance?

64

By ethel smith

Labour leader Gordon Brown can sometimes appear dour and worn out
See all 4 photos
Labour leader Gordon Brown can sometimes appear dour and worn out
Conservative leader David Cameron has youth on his side, like Tony Blair in his early days. How genuine is he though?
Conservative leader David Cameron has youth on his side, like Tony Blair in his early days. How genuine is he though?
Nick Clegg as leader of the Liberal party which often just makes up the numbers has a mountain to climb.
Nick Clegg as leader of the Liberal party which often just makes up the numbers has a mountain to climb.
The stage will be set
The stage will be set

With a UK General Election looming in early May 2010 the British Public are having election news hurled at them constantly. It would seem that there is no other news in the world. Turn on British Television news and you will be bombarded with election updates and coverage. In between programs, Party Political Election Broadcasts are aired in an attempt to catch those voters who may still be undecided.

Politicians in the UK have a mountain to climb in this election campaign. With the global financial crisis, and Members of Parliament’s expenses scandal, still fresh in any people’s minds there are many voters who will just stay away from the polls. Building trust again is paramount.

All of this though could have a detrimental effect on our next Government.

The British National Party will hope to utilise these negatives and gain seats, and many people are predicting that the Liberals may hold the balance of power in a hung parliament. A hung parliament would mean that there was no outright leader and various political parties could have to work together and form an allegiance. This has some advantages but, overall, could mean that little was achieved.

The British Electorate then has plenty to chew over in the next few weeks.

Added to this immense coverage we will now have Political debate US style broadcast on mainstream Television.

There has already been such a debate between the Chancellors of each of the three main parties. Tonight, 15th April 2010, there will be the first debate between the three main leaders. As the American debates have shown, there will be many crucial aspects such as:-

  • Who stands where?
  • What image should they portray?
  • What will persuade the voter?
  • Who will have that extra something, namely voter appeal?

Really though the issues should be more important than such trivialities.

Personally, I already know which party I will vote for but, for some, this debate could be significant. However, I am undecided if this should be the case.

Most of the audience, me included, will not be trained in reading body language and will find it hard to uncover what is true and what is propaganda.

As possible heir apparent David Cameron, who will be standing centre stage, perhaps has the best position. He also has many positives for such a debate. He is youthful, fresh and fairly new. For many floating voters he could be just who they think they want.

These debates though could mean that we simply get style over substance in our political leader.

If I had not already made my mind up, I think that I would boycott these debates. As those in America have shown, those politicians with TV flair, presence and style sometimes make good leaders but more often than not, they do not.

Either way, if you are even vaguely interested in politics, the debates could make for fascinating viewing. Then again they may be just one big bore. For the opposition leader it will be a great platform to show himself off. He after all has nothing to lose but the promise of what could be.

It has been reported today that David Cameron, Tory leader, has been told to try not to come across as smug, as he so often does. I guess in the end then it will come down to who is the best actor and TV personality rather than who would be the best leader for Great Britain right now.

What do you think?

Are televised political debates-

  • Pointless
  • Useful
  • Fascinating
  • Boring
  • My feelings depend on the participants
See results without voting

UK political debates

  • PM: Euro to 'make-up or break-up'

    Prime Minister David Cameron says the eurozone must make a decision soon on whether to stay together. - 7 hours ago

  • New faces on Tory 1922 committee

    Conservative backbenchers elect the executive body of their influential 1922 committee, with newer MPs regarded as being more supportive of the coalition gaining ground. - 60 minutes ago

  • Heckled May defends police change

    Home Secretary Theresa May denies her relationship with the police is beyond repair after she was heckled at the Police Federation conference. - 91 minutes ago

  • UK unemployment falls by 45,000

    UK unemployment fell by 45,000 to 2.63 million in the three months to March, according to the Office for National Statistics. - 6 hours ago

  • Hague 'to fight for UK business'

    Foreign Secretary William Hague will promise to "argue relentlessly" for free trade around the world in an effort to boost the UK economy. - 5 hours ago

  • UK database to track unpaid fines

    A new 24 hour national police database is to be rolled out to target criminals who do not pay their fines. - 6 hours ago

  • Murdoch 'enjoys MPs' power game'

    Media mogul Rupert Murdoch enjoys playing a "power game" with politicians, former Foreign Secretary Jack Straw says. - 8 hours ago

  • Howe: Time for UK to go metric

    The UK's two measurement systems are a "confusing shambles" and must be reformed, former foreign secretary Lord Howe says. - 11 hours ago

Comments

ethel smith profile image

ethel smith Hub Author 2 years ago

Its terrible. Heaven only knows where it will all end.

michael brannigan profile image

michael brannigan 2 years ago

Let's be honest. It doesn't matter which one of them gets elected Prime Minister, Brown sold us to the IMF when he 'bailed' out the banks. The economic direction of the next budget has been set: massive cuts in public expenditure and a hike in taxation. Greece has shown how the game is to be played out and we will follow. Just to add insult to our injuries, the German Tax Payer will buy up our railways and buses, cause they can afford to. Unless UK PLC they didn't privatise their assets and so have a direct earning return to their treasure through Nationalised Utilities. Something, we were told was defunct and archaic.

ethel smith profile image

ethel smith Hub Author 2 years ago

Thanks Habee, you to.

It comes and it goes though lol

habee profile image

habee Level 7 Commenter 2 years ago

Great hub! Girlfriend, congrats on the 100!!

ethel smith profile image

ethel smith Hub Author 2 years ago

Yes he does seem flavour of the month right now. I wonder what will happen between now and 6th May. As they say a day is a long time in politics :)

premierkj profile image

premierkj 2 years ago

Ethel, I was going to vote on your poll but my answer wasn't there! It's quite obvious even now that these TV debates will decide the outcome even though they are personality contests. Nick Clegg won the debate on most of the polls simply because people grew tired of the other two bickering. He won because he stayed in the shadows and was slightly less annoying than anybody else. Suddenly the media love him and the snow ball is rolling.

ethel smith profile image

ethel smith Hub Author 2 years ago

Thanks for stopping by Amanda.Perhaps you thought DC was the best performer as he is your chosen one? I think our perception has a lot to do with our preference.

Amanda Severn profile image

Amanda Severn Level 3 Commenter 2 years ago

Hi Ethel, like you, I already know who I will be voting for, but I still watched the debate nevertheless. For me, and many others that I have spoken to, David Cameron emerged as the strongest candidate, so I was surprised to see the newspapers giving the laurels to Nick Clegg. The newspapers are busy manipulating the electorate in time-honoured tradition, but I fear for the outcome, as a hung parliament might not be the best thing for the country.

ethel smith profile image

ethel smith Hub Author 2 years ago

Hi all. Just comping a little for now.

Thanks for the visits.

Hello I know what you mean but we will just have to hope for the best.

I agree about the limited audience. There were also many ground rules to be obeyed.

Will catch up when recovered. love to you all

Eileen Hughes profile image

Eileen Hughes Level 3 Commenter 2 years ago

ethel another great hub leaving us with something to think about. I do the poling booths on some of the elections over here. And I just hate the drama and waste of our money on all the tv coverage and worst of all the waste of paper at the poling booths. There should be an easier way. Online or something.

And to be honest (we all know it) Not many of the voters care they go in and do not even fill out the papers so its just of time and energy. Great hub though

rprcarz50 profile image

rprcarz50 2 years ago

I think the USA also basis voting more on style than it seems. Although Carisma is very big in the US also.

Very good content !

Thank you for this Hub

Ron

As Always also a2z50

billyaustindillon profile image

billyaustindillon Level 2 Commenter 2 years ago

The problem with political debates seems to be they hand pick the audience and political bias of the interviewer or host. In other words you rarely get a real debate.

sweetie1 profile image

sweetie1 2 years ago

really nice and thought provoking hub..thanks and it is all over the world i think. In India no one talk about development.. All politicians would talk about who they would include in list of reserved classes so those castes or groups can corner Govt jobs, seats in prestigious colleges for free and without good marks and get govt grants and loans which they would never have to return because govt is going to write those off soon provided they got elected.

Hello, hello, profile image

Hello, hello, 2 years ago

Hello, ethel, and thank you for such a straight forward hub. I am worried sick about the outcome.

ethel smith profile image

ethel smith Hub Author 2 years ago

Sorry Tony my comment is above but I was not signed in. Silly woman :)

 2 years ago

Hope you enjoy it then Tony.

I shall be giving it a whirl.

Its just that some of the best politicians in the past have not been shall we say personable and our worst ones have been photgenic and charismatic.

tonymac04 profile image

tonymac04 2 years ago

I would actually like to see the debates tonight, but guess I will have to wait until they are shown on our new tomorrow.

Thanks for sharing

Love and peace

Tony

Submit a Comment
Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.



    • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
    • Comments are not for promoting your Hubs or other sites

    Please wait working